In his paper, updating evolutionary epistemology, christophe heintz critically analyzes evolutionary epistemology as a theoretical framework for the study of science as a historical and cultural phenomenon. Donald campbell 63 advocacy of experimental methods led him to be branded a logical positivist among evaluators who did not know his corpus of works, it is clear he rejected that philosophy of science in favor of evolutionary epistemology, a weak relativist sociology of knowledge, and an appreciation for cultural relativism. Popper, otto selz, and the rise of evolutionary epistemology. Evolutionary epistemology refers to three distinct topics. Evolutionary epistemology internet encyclopedia of. Evolutionary epistemology must therefore draw a fundamental connection between adaptation and knowledge. However, he repeatedly refused to be called the founding father of ee since he saw himself as denoting something that has sprung up all over for a hundred years or more campbell in callebaut, 1993.
The idea that knowledge depends on the evolution of. Evolutionary epistemology a multiparadigm program w. He coined the term evolutionary epistemology and developed a selectionist theory of human creativity. Variation and selective retention as an evolutionary. Existing frameworks in evolutionary epistemology do this in two ways. Bayesian methods since the time of laplace have been understood by their practitioners as closely aligned to the scientific method. Evolutionary epistemology of donald t campbell was carried out by me under the supervision of prof. Evolutionary epistemology evolutionary epistemology is an approach that sees knowledge in the first place as a product of the variation and selection processes characterizing evolution.
It notes, first, that the original function of knowledge is to make survival and reproduction of the organism that uses it. Campbell to describe a new stream in epistemology, which incorporates the evolution theory by charles darwin. T campbell, evolutionary epistemology, evolutionary epistemology, rationality, and the sociology of knowledge 1987. Evolutionary epistemology is a naturalistic approach to epistemology. Quoting a passage from the autobiographical essay in. Updating evolutionary epistemology christophe heintz. Jean piaget, origins of intelligence in childrennew york. Implications for evaluators, researchers, practitioners, funders and the evidencebased program mandate this paper offers a way of thinking about program development that has deep theoretical. It notes, first, that the original function of knowledge is to make survival and reproduction of the organism that uses it more likely. Richard dawkins devised a special version of evolutionary epistemology. Pdf my dissertation focuses mainly on evolutionary epistemology of mechanisms eem and general selection theory gst versions of.
The term evolutionary epistemology was coined by donald campbell 1974. It is in the area of methodology development, however, where many of the most important contributions have been made. Converging views from philosophy, the natural and the social sciences. The concept evolutionary epistemology was first introduced by donald t. Evolutionary epistemology, rationality, and the sociology of. Evolutionary epistemology philosophy oxford bibliographies. My dissertation concludes how campbell s naturalistic evolutionary epistemology is developed or supported by later evolutionary epistemologists and what repercussions it can have on. Osborn to the extent that science and monasticism both seek clearer understanding and greater knowledge in their respective fields, there is the potential for the application of scientific facts and theorizing to monasticism. Evolutionary epistemology, meditation, and merton by don r. This is a relatively uncommon type of endeavor in that. The field of evolutionary epistemology presents the evolution of systems of knowledge, including science, in terms of a darwinian process. Universal selection theory and the second darwinian revolution the mit press, 1997.
It is the first coherent epistemological program that 1s empirically grounded 2, and under the leadership of don campbell it has shown none of the predeterminations with which philosophers of sc1ence tend to fend off. Evolutionary epistemology aims at providing a causal history of scientific knowledge. Evolutionary epistemology bibliography springerlink. Classification and evolution in biology, linguistics and. D t campbell has used the expression evolutionary epistemology to describe epistemological theories from poincare and mach to popper that saw the evolution of human knowledge as a process that progresses by trial and errorelimination, creating new hypotheses and selectively eliminating false ones. Scientific thought is generally characterized as methodical and rational. Bayesian methods and universal darwinism john campbell abstract. Evolutionary epistemology, rationality, and the sociology. Explanations of the evolution of science itself have been framed in terms of a darwinian processes by prominent philosophers of science including karl popper and donald campbell popper, 1972. In his contribution to the 1974 schilpp volume on karl popper, campbell described bvsr as the basis for an evolutionary epistemology, based on many of the ideas of popper. Whereas other approaches to evolutionary epistemology, such as that of konrad lorenz, remained silent on the actual relation of the ontogeny of knowledge to its phylogeny, or indeed on the basic character of knowledge itself in relation to the interaction of organisms with their environment campbell, 1975b, campbells ee took into account.
Also included are works introducing and discussing the general topic of evolutionary epistemology, such as bradie and harms 2017, gontier 2006. He is less well known within the evaluation community for his landmark contributions to biology and philosophy. In the present essay it is also argued that evolution even. The traditional problems in epistemology led to the binary oppositions of descartes, kant, etc.
My dissertation concludes how campbells naturalistic evolutionary epistemology is developed or supported by later evolutionary epistemologists and what repercussions it can have on. Some of these contributions are principally theoretical, for example, social judgment theory hammond 1980 and evolutionary epistemology campbell 1974, 1996. Jaynes, titled his textbook on the subject probability theory. Evolutionary epistemology is the attempt to address questions in the theory of knowledge from an evolutionary point of view. A third recent proponent of epistemology as an empirical, descriptive discipline is the psychologist donald campbell. Evolutionary epistemology stanford encyclopedia of. It has not been submitted for any other diploma or degree either in part or in full to this or to any other university. Campbell introduces evolutionary epistemology as a research program in descriptive epistemology that would be at a minimum an epistemology taking cognizance of and compatible with mans status as a product of biological and social evolution evolutionary 4. Genetic epistemology and piagets philosophy of science. Recent proponents of evolutionary epistemology include the psychologist donald campbell 1974a, the sociobiologist richard daw kins 1976, and philosophers of science karl popper 1972, stephen toulmin 1972, and robert ackerman 1970. Anevolutionaryepistemologywouldbeat minimumanepistemologytakingcognizanceof andcompatiblewithmansstatusasaproductof biologicalandsocialevolution. Events in the external world are perceived through an evolutionary cognitive apparatus a neurosensory system that acquired its. The primary concern of epistemology is the acquistion of knowledge. Mckelvey bases his approach on evolutionary epistemology donald campbell s version, nonequilibrium thermodynamics, evolutionary biology, complexity theory and concepts of organizational heredity as introduced by nelson and winter 1982.
Evolutionary epistemology an overview sciencedirect topics. From evolutionary epistemology via selection theory to a sociology of scientific validity. This is a successor to the most complete previous bibliography campbell, d. Pdf evolutionary epistemology, rationality, and the. He coined the term evolutionary epistemology and developed a selectionist. Evolutionary epistemology of donald t campbell full thesis. Evolutionary epistemology, rationality, and the sociology of knowledge gerard radnitzky and w. Campbell it has shown none of the predeterminations with which philosophers of sc1ence tend to fend off sociological inroads upon their territory. In his earlier work campbell advocated an evolutionary epistemology, and his recent william james lectures characterize his conception as descriptive epistemology. The basic issues are discussed in barbel inhelder and jean piaget, the early growth of logic in the child. Campbells descriptive evolutionary epistemology enables us to do precisely that. One is the study of the evolution of the cognitive apparatus of living organisms, which is first and foremost the province of biologists and psychologists h. Quoting a passage from the autobiographical essay in conjectures and. Declaration i hereby declare that the work reported in this dissertation entitled evolutionary epistemology of donald t campbell was carried out by me under the supervision of prof.
A biological theory of knowledge and applications to real. The evolutionary naturalistic epistemology of donald t. It is argued that while campbell s experimental methodology is still the reigning evaluation orthodoxy, the introduction of a materialistphysicalist theory of knowledge provides an important first step toward the redefinition of the study and practice. Through his unique disposition to engage in fierce but always amicable intellectual exchange across disciplinary boundaries, inspiring teaching, and more than 240. Campbell s descriptive evolutionary epistemology enables us to do precisely that. An evolutionary expistemology would be at minimum an epistemology taking cognizance of and compatible with mans status as a product of biological and social evolution. We would appreciate receipt of information about, and reprints of, such items.
Bethlehem, pennsylvania, 6 may 1996, psychology, anthropology, methodology of social science, education, evolutionary theory, epistemology, science studies. Prajit k basu, center for neural and cognitive sciences, university of hyderabad, hyderabad. Evolutionary epistemology, rationality, and the sociology of knowledge gerard radnitzky, w. It is argued that while campbells experimental methodology is still the reigning evaluation orthodoxy, the introduction of a materialistphysicalist theory of knowledge provides an important first step toward the redefinition of the study and practice. Campbell 1974 coined the term evolutionary epistemology in an essay about poppers theories of conceptual change to refer to this interdisciplinary endeavour to find generalising descriptions of knowledge development. Campbell suny series in philosophy and biology heyes, cecilia, hull, david l. Yet, the evolutionary epistemology that he pioneered has significant implications for evaluation. As spelled out by campbell in the 1970s, evolutionary epistemology has an ambitious goal. Donald thomas campbell november 20, 1916 may 5, 1996 was an american social scientist. Evolutionary epistemology stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. In fact, campbell s challenge to sociology of sc1ence to come up with interesting answers to the many problems of scientific change is serious and sincere. Campbell, a scientist, humanist, and generalist, left an indelible mark on the evaluation discipline through his methodological work. Evolutionary epistemology extends the darwinian notion of biological evolution to cognitive mechanisms donald campbell 81 04alkin.
Evolutionary epistemology internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Essays in evolu tionary epistemology, new york, wiley, 1984, although quite a few philosophers professional or vocational have. This represents paradigmatic biological evolution through natural selection. He and popper both saw evolution itself as a knowledge process, and that the natural selection paradigm could be generalized to other epistemic activities, such as. The evolutionary epistemology according to popper 1984 the term evolutionary epistemology was created by donald t. Evolutionary epistemology involves, in part, deploying models and metaphors drawn from evolutionary biology in the attempt to characterize and resolve issues arising in epistemology and conceptual change. I would like to present here an opposing view which treats science as a nonsystematic activity, where serendipity and tinkering, rather than socalled rational thought, characterizes it. I am simplifying some matters of empirical method here. Campbell, ranks among the modern advocates of evolutionary epistemology, a research programme that is inspired by the notion that darwins principles of variation, selection, and retention can explain all domains, from biology to. Bayesian methods and universal darwinism revised 092309. Variation and selective retention as an evolutionary epistemology. The primary outcome of natural selection is adaptation to an environment. Evolutionary epistemology, of which popper was one of the promoters, comprises two programmes. Pdf evolutionary epistemology of donald t campbell full.
58 657 1362 486 317 415 8 717 369 734 1134 235 783 865 849 1153 113 1506 420 900 894 1384 224 349 813 1116 1064 735 1028 811 1458 514 916 1433 921 483 1544 875 37 316 1408 1401 104 534 1167